Oliver Burke and the Question of Re-signing Former Players

Oli Burke - playing for Alaves

Oliver Burke is for sale. 4 years after the then teenager appeared to have the world at his feet and left Forest for RB Leipzig, there is a question of resigning him.

There would be numerous problems with that before we even touch on should we go for him. It still won’t be cheap. He cost West Brom £15 million just three years ago. Even with Premiership money they aren’t going to just write off that figure, as he also has two years left on that contract. And a five year deal signed in a £15 mill deal when West Brom were in the Premiership, he is going to have high wages (the reports when he went to Leipzig saw some eye watering figures for a untested youngsters bandied about)

So Burke is available. And could fit into our counter attacking system. He knows the club, and was a popular player so could be a good fit.

We have returned for players before. If you go back beyond my times we bought back John Robertson and Garry Birtles. More into my era, Steve Hodge and Neil Webb both came back, Des Walker came home and more recently so too have Andy Reid and Michael Dawson.

However in a few of those cases its players at the end of their career, in the twilight of their playing days coming back. Not a player coming back in his peak years. Look across football. It doesn’t happen all that much,  especially in England.  You could easily argue in all of those cases above, the player that came back was a far diminished version of the player who left.

And that argument of a diminished player returning would be very much the case with a Burke return. If he were to reignite his career would he want to stick around. I don’t think there’s a chance right now of a Premier League team taking him on because he has simply failed to make the grade at the top level. One of Leipzig’s criticisms was that he wasn’t an intelligent player. But in a stable environment getting games he could turn out to be an astute buy.

Without major outgoings I can’t see us laying out the £6-7 million I think would be necessary to bring Burke back. I can’t see the club approving many multi million deals, especially on a player who has struggled for a few years. Similarly an expensive buy would see a long contract, and look at how we got lumbered with Clough for a number of years with no takers. I’m not saying Burke is like Clough, Burke has gone places to get regular game time, whereas Clough has wallowed.

We are also linked with Kieron Freeman who left the club as a youngster. Unlike Burke he never really broke through at Forest. Unlike Burke he would be relatively cost effective. He knows the city which can help.

Moving for a former player isn’t always going backwards. Burke moved to go onto bigger things that didn’t quite pan out. So its not quite a step backwards. But it would be a risk

Kieron Freeman

Comments